Goodbye, For Now

Coaster Critic Updates

I was working at PBS. It was a very creative work environment and I was working with people who were artists in their free time. It wasn’t unusual to talk about our personal endeavors and hobbies. I must have mentioned that I wanted to create a roller coaster website.

One day I was talking to my boss when he had a suggestion for me.”I looked into it and there aren’t many theme park blogs. You should create one.” he said.

“A blog?” I thought.

It was early 2006. The term had just become familiar to me. And it had reached overused, buzzword status behind the scenes at PBS thanks to our newly created Media Shift blog. The surprising amount of attention and my misconception that a blog was no more than a public diary, made me initially scoff at the idea.

The Beginning of the Blog

The Coaster Critic's Blog Over the YearsI’m not sure what changed my mind. It was probably the ease of setting up a site at Blogger. Anyway, after picking a name that I thought was fitting (since I’ve always loved reviews and critiques of any kind), I dubbed my site “The Coaster Critic’s Blog”. As a side note, CoasterCritic.com was taken, by a dormant site. So I wasn’t technically the original Coaster Critic. I bought TheCoasterCritic.com and later bought CoasterCritic.com when it became available.

I opened the virtual doors back in April of 2006. I wrote for myself as an outlet, but also for friends and family who’d ask about the regional parks in my part of the country like Kings Dominion, Six Flags America, and Busch Gardens Williamsburg. I figured I could point them to my site when they asked if there were any good roller coasters at Busch Gardens, or if they should visit our local Six Flags.

Thanks to my day job, where I analyzed volumes of website traffic, I applied my analytic skills to my hobby and started noticing that there were actually people out there reading my posts. I still never thought the site would grow very much. Once I started to get responses to my posts via comments, I knew that I wasn’t really writing just for myself and my friends anymore. I was only one person, but I could actually contribute to the theme park world on the Web in some way.

What I Learned About Blogs

Blogs weren’t diaries or a one-way medium like I thought. Or at least they didn’t have to be. They’re superior to traditional websites from an engagement standpoint since they’re inherently built for discussion thanks to the comments section. So, I invited and encouraged readers to respond. I thought about the types of posts that readers might want to read and react to the most (like the 250+ comment post comparing Kingda Ka to Top Thrill Dragster).

What I Learned About Myself & Side Projects

I created several side projects. They were always secondary to the blog and quite often I either lost interest or they became too difficult to maintain. Over the years I’ve learned about what motivates me and why I always needed to have something else in development in the proverbial lab. Hopefully, it wasn’t too frustrating for visitors who saw some of those sites come and go. I’ll take all that I’ve learned about myself and balance my inability to wear 16 different hats at the same time with my innate need to dabble with something new. If you have questions or proposals about Theme Parker or Hype contact me. I’m not sure what I’m going to do with them.

Digital Journalism

From the beginning, I wrote opinionated reviews (my first main calling), trip reports, and I tried a few park reviews, but then realized that I don’t typically experience enough of a park to write an accurate full park review. I wrote rants about bad coaster names and also started to write about theme park news. My posts on new roller coasters and big news stories was probably what attracted reporters looking for a subject matter expert. They had criminologists, lawyers, medical experts, but who do you call for a piece on Pennsylvania’s Good Old-fashioned Thrill Rides (woodies)? Predicting that Waldameer’s Ravine Flyer II might be the best new ride of 2008 resulted in my first quote in a major news outlet.

Bob Mampe - Bolliger & MabillardI tried to learn from each interview and really listen for the viewpoint of the non-coaster fan and the general public. I couldn’t see the World from my viewpoint, I had to consider how the other 99.9% of the public sees our beloved roller coasters. I also tried my hand at interviewing theme park owners, ride designers, and even other theme park website creators.

I did my best to carefully report the news. I always cited my sources by linking to them (professional blogging 101) and if something was a rumor, I made it clear. I’m sure I made a mistake or two along the way, but in some small way the site was a news outlet getting out the news of ride announcements, accidents, theme park and ride closures and acquisitions for years.

Keepin’ it Clean!

The Web can be a wild place. People think that since they have the ability to say anything that they want, that they should say anything. And now we have comments on YouTube and CNN (just for example) that are some of the most hateful and unproductive things I’ve ever read.

I felt that the best way to encourage and allow for healthy debate and discussion was to ban inappropriate language and personal attacks of any kind. This was not easy. I’ve done my best to moderate comments and do what I could to catch horrible stuff that you’ve thankfully never seen get posted. I knew that the site would be better for it and based on some of the comments by readers I see that it was worth it as the clean, level-headed discussions were generally the hallmark of the site.

In addition, the family-friendly content has led to the site being used as a resource by classes, individually by kids looking to do projects, and I’ve even heard from parents that enjoy checking it out with their kids. As a parent, I can appreciate a safe and fun site that I can visit without worrying. And regardless of the family-friendliness, I feel that there is a lot of value in creating a place where people can openly talk to each other with respect while using words you’d find in the dictionary. My next project will aim to do the same.

The Secret of The Blog’s Success: Talking to the Masses, Not Just the Geeks

As I mentioned above, I tried to view the theme park world that I knew and loved so well, from the viewpoint of those who barely knew much about it. Rather than laugh at the comments and thoughts of the general public because of their lack of theme park knowledge, as some of us do, I tried to inform and educate.

The Coasterology posts, the way I reference parks: “Six Flags Magic Mountain (near Los Angeles)” instead of just “SFMM”, and not assuming people knew the terminology and coaster jargon was all done to bring new fans and the general public into the discussion. As the site grew, I remembered who I was writing for. There’s nothing wrong with writing just for theme park geeks, but that just wasn’t my goal. And, I don’t think the site would have grown as much as it did if I hadn’t written this way.

A Final Thanks to My Biggest Supporters

I thanked the many friends and collaborators that have joined me on this journey, but I should also thank my biggest supporters, my family. Thanks to my parents for always being supportive of their son’s strange hobby. Thanks to my wife, Jenn, for holding down the fort while I was on some long distance trip riding coasters in another part of the country. And, thanks to my big brother for his much needed technical help over the years. I couldn’t have done this without you.

Time to Say Goodbye, For Now

While I’ve had a blast it’s time for me to move on. It’s been amazing to be able to travel the country experiencing great rides and parks and then sharing those experiences with you. I’ve literally rocketed to the top of the coaster World on Kingda Ka, sped through the subterranean masterpiece that is The Voyage, been tossed around like a rag doll on the extreme rides like X2 and Intimidator 305, and had unforgettable experiences like my night ride on The Beast. And I’ve had fun doing it all with you.

As I stated last December, I’ve lost my passion for writing about theme parks. I still love visiting them, but writing about them regularly has felt like more of a chore than a joy. My interest, as a writer, has shifted from the world of theme parks to a new frontier. I say “Goodbye, For Now”, because I hope that you’ll check out my future endeavors.

I will no longer update the site with new posts, but I’ll make sure that it’s still available for those who are researching opinions on roller coasters and theme parks. I’ll also occasionally add a post or two to chronicle my less frequent theme park adventures. Next month I’ll be visiting Hersheypark and I’ll have to check out the rumored coaster coming to Carowinds next year. If you subscribe here, you’ll automatically get all of my future posts by email. You can also follow me on Facebook as I’ll still post updates there occasionally too.

Thanks again! I’ll see you at the parks. I might be accompanied by a budding coaster fan (or two).Signing Off

18 Comments

  1. I just wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading all the posts/reviews/etc on here. 🙂 (I do tend to ‘not comment’ a lot though…I just read:))

    Thanks for leaving the site up so everyone can still read it!:)

    Reply
  2. Its a shame about the site but theres no point doing something you dont enjoy. Thanks for the site and ill look forward to reading your trip reports.

    Good luck in whatever you do!

    Reply
  3. This has been, to me, the definitive website for information and reviews about roller coasters. I would like to have used Joel as a role model in setting up my own website but could never meet his high standards. A sad goodbye!

    Reply
    • Thanks Bobbie. Feel free to let me know if you have any questions at all about your site. That goes for anyone else too. I’m always willing to share what I’ve learned. Good luck!

      Reply
  4. I have been reading every post for the last 3 years, and I want to thank you for the great ride. This site has been a huge help to get though the long winter season in Ohio.

    Thanks for being awesome!

    Reply
  5. Thanks for leaving the blogsite up, As I told you recently, it has become my “happy place” during recent turmoil in my own life. I love sending you pictures and have a feeling that that will be a hard habit to break, especially since I-305 claimed my old flip phone and I have entered the 21st century by buying an iphone. It takes fantastic photos! Thank you for the shout-out in yesterday’s post, I was truly honored!

    Reply
  6. You can still keep in touch via the contact page or by posting something on the Facebook page.

    Thanks everyone for the kind comments. Again, it wouldn’t have been as fun without sharing and discussing my experiences with you.

    Reply
  7. I Didn’t really comment much but I enjoyed reading all your posts over the last few years. You’re a great author, have a great hobby, and are a good person

    Reply
  8. Good Luck!

    Reply
    • Thanks Julie. It’s been good working with you.

      Reply
  9. Thank you, Joel, for your coaster blog these past several years. I have always been a huge coaster addict, and your blog has been helpful during the long, coaster-less Midwestern winters. It’s been nice to read about new coasters for the upcoming seasons, and to plan summer coaster trips. Best wishes in your future endeavors!

    Reply
  10. Thanks for everything Joel!

    Reply
  11. Joel, I really enjoyed reading all the scholarly, detailed reviews of coasters you have on this site! I actually used two of them (Kraken, Manta) for a trip I took to Sea World a couple of weeks ago. I wish you all the best and hopefully you will add on to what you did on this site.

    I also was pleased to find that I’m not alone in being a coaster “addict”! One last question: what exactly is an Immelman? I have found definitions of it in technical terms but I still can’t grasp it!

    Reply
  12. Hey Joel I know you probably don’t check your blog anymore but I really enjoyed your articles on roller coaster news and reviews. Good luck with whatever you write about next.

    Reply
  13. Joel, I had the following questions I wanted to email you but couldn’t find your email address anywhere and believe it or not, I”m NOT on Facebook.

    I really love your site! It’s got great detailed, scholarly writeups.
    I have some questions for you about rides that maybe you can answer:

    Questions:
    1) I am having a hard time understanding certain loops like Dive Loop
    and Immelmann, even after reading definitions. How would you explain
    these and other loops in layman’s terms? Is there a site you could
    recommend that has pictures and descriptions?
    I’ve probably been thru these kinds of loops on rides like Batman,
    Superman or X Flight but didn’t know it!

    2) I’m always very curious about the physics, engineering and
    construction of rides. For the typical coaster, by B & M ride (i.e
    Batman, Superman, etc) is the track itself solid steel or tubular? Are
    the support posts solid or tubular, or filled with concrete?

    3) What do you think of the new Goliath at Six Flags Great America (if
    it ever opens) ? How well will the wooden track hold up, considering
    that it’s got a super steep drop and some crazy inversions? I’m just
    wondering if it wont get warped or bend over time.

    4) What do you think Six Flags will do with the American Eagle at
    Great America? I’m thinking it will follow the same fate as Colossus
    at Magic Mountain.

    Steve

    Reply
  14. Hello and goodbye! I’ve just found your site after somewhat avoiding coasters for the last several years since I’ve grown older and more rickety myself. Coasters in general just make me sad these days because of the declining interest so it is no surprise that someone like yourself would move on. For now, I will enjoy reading your past reviews and experiences here. Thank you!

    Reply
  15. If you can name a coaster that supposedly has an “immelman,” then I can explain it. I honestly forget at the moment but it would come back to me with a name.

    Reply
  16. I am so sorry to see you hang it up. Yours was one of the best sites on this topic in design and writing. Thanks for allowing me to share some of my experiences as well.

    Good luck with your future endeavors.

    Sincerely,
    Darryl (aka BlackDaddy) from baltimore

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*

Lost Password